Kodeks karny wykonawczy (k.k.w.)

02:12 Dec 18, 2015 

Legacy translations...
Długo by o tym opowiadać.... Każdy, kto ma do czynienia np. z kwestionariuszami jakości życia osób przewlekle chorych wie, że te chronione prawem autorskim koszmary są nie do ruszenia, choćby straszyły po nocach.
Z tej perspektywy, "executive" wydaje się bardzo wybaczalny

23:34 Dec 17, 2015 

@Tomasz Poplawski: I will go with your argument based on accepted usage and yield to your experience.

17:27 Dec 17, 2015 

There is another perennial struggle, for consistency between the existing documents, and newly created ones.
Frank, I'm not saying the word "executive" makes a lot of sense. But the fact is, as you see from the links, that it has been used, for better or worse, in a variety of Internet sources, many of them quite official. Does it mean an absolute prohibition against creating a different translation? Of course not - it's just like a judge going against previous court decisions in the common law system. However, in both cases, the threshold is higher when something is already out there, and unless it is just horrible, the tendency is to accept it.

11:36 Dec 17, 2015 

Observe a previous answer on the same subject
Polish term or phrase: prawo karne wykonawcze
English translation: criminal punishment law
Entered by: Polangmar
http://www.proz.com/kudoz/polish_to_english/law_general/4636...

01:07 Dec 17, 2015 

There is the perennial struggle to translate not only words but also concepts to a foreign audience. Would a British or an American lawyer relate to "executive" in relation to the penal code? The word carries different connotations in English.

18:36 Dec 16, 2015 

A UK address, although authors are Polish, I would assume there's some editing involved
http://www.crimeandjustice.org.uk/sites/crimeandjustice.org....
UK governmental source:
https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachm...

13:16 Dec 16, 2015 

This may have been the original source for the translation I used:
http://tlumaczenia-ustne.biz/kodeks-cywilny-karny-postepowan...

13:09 Dec 16, 2015 

Interestingly, when I tried to google executive penal code, the only source I found was that on proz. The ones that appear in the link provided by Colleague Poplawski are Polish sources. I do not see such a concept in Western sources. For an executive code there would have to be a non-executive code, I surmise. My link lists a number of penal codes -
Kodeks celny Customs Code k.cel.
Kodeks cywilny Civil Code k.c.
Kodeks karny Criminal Code k.k.
Kodeks karny skarbowy Tax Penal Code k.k.s
Kodeks karny wykonawczy Corrections Code k.k.w.
Kodeks morski Maritime Code k.m.
Kodeks postępowania administracyjnego Code of Administrative Procedure k.p.a.
Kodeks postępowania cywilnego Code of Civil Procedure k.p.c.
Kodeks postępowania karnego Code of Criminal Procedure k.p.k.
Kodeks postępowania w sprawach o wykroczenia Code of Procedure for Violations k.p.w.
Kodeks pracy Labor Code k.p.
Kodeks rodzinny i opiekuńczy Family and Custody Code k.r.o.
Kodeks spółek handlowych Business Organizations Code k.s.h.
Kodeks wykroczeń Violations Code k.w.

yet when it came to the executive code, it chose to used a different term. Can someone comment on this question, please?

02:08 Dec 16, 2015 

http://www.proz.com/kudoz/polish_to_english/law_general/1932...

Ta odpowiedź pozostaje nadal słuszna, co potwierdzi proste przezukiwanie sieci