Glossary entry

English term or phrase:

Discrete Device Assignment

Spanish translation:

asignación discreta de dispositivos

Added to glossary by Víctor Zamorano
Jun 17, 2023 10:39
11 mos ago
20 viewers *
English term

Discrete Device Assignment

English to Spanish Tech/Engineering Computers: Systems, Networks Windows Server
Una característica de Windows Server. Yo entiendo que es "asignación de dispositivos discretos", pero veo tanto "asignación discreta de dispositivos" que ya dudo.

Gracias!

Discussion

Juan Gil Jun 17, 2023:
@Víctor Discrete
clearly separate or different in shape or form.
Synonyms: independent, separate
https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/discrete

constituting a separate entity : individually distinct
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/discrete

Es claro que los dispositivos son distintos, por lo cual sería redundante que lo discrete se refiera a ellos: esto hace que lo discrete sea la asignación.

Asignación discreta de dispositivos = Asignación individual de dispositivos.

Jennifer tiene razón (y lo que entiendes está errado, es lo que te aparece, lo que te hizo dudar).
Víctor Zamorano (asker) Jun 17, 2023:
No sirven refs. de Microsoft Learn Hola Hernán, gracias por el intento, pero las referencias de Learn no son fiables, como dice Jennifer son incoherentes (precisamente de eso se trata...).
Hernan Casasbuenas Jun 17, 2023:
Buenos días Victor Mira esto, creo que te puede ayudar
https://learn.microsoft.com/es-es/windows-server/virtualizat...

Proposed translations

+3
3 hrs
Selected

asignación discreta de dispositivos

Although, as Asker has mentioned in the discussion box, translations in Microsoft Learn are unreliable (blame MT for that!), it is nonetheless clear from the following extracts which explain the purpose of of DDA in both English and Spanish, that 'DDA' refers to the 'discrete assignment' / asignación discreta of 'devices' / dispositivos. IWO, 'discrete' qualifies 'deployment', not 'devices'.

EN
https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows-server/virtualizat...
Starting with Windows Server 2016, you can use Discrete Device Assignment, or DDA, to pass an entire PCIe Device into a VM
...
There are three steps to using a device with Discrete Device Assignment:
Configure the VM for Discrete Device Assignment
Dismount the Device from the Host Partition
Assigning the Device to the Guest VM

ES
https://learn.microsoft.com/es-es/windows-server/virtualizat...
A partir de Windows Server 2016, puede usar la asignación discreta de dispositivos o DDA para pasar un dispositivo PCIe completo a una máquina virtual.
...
Hay tres pasos para usar un dispositivo con asignación discreta de dispositivos:
Configuración de la máquina virtual para la asignación discreta de dispositivos
Desmontar el dispositivo de la partición de host
Asignación del dispositivo a la máquina virtual invitada

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 3 hrs (2023-06-17 14:10:23 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

@Asker's comment below:
La que más me convence es intel
(https://www.intel.es/content/www/es/es/support/articles/0000...
en el sentido de que los gráficos (tarjetas) son periféricos. Aquí se ve
discreto/periférico vs integrado.


In the context of Windows Server, and DDA in particular which is concerned with optimising the use of resources in a virtual machine, it is irrelevant whether the device is physically integrado or a periférico.


--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 7 hrs (2023-06-17 17:45:52 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

Further clarification (although this really isn't the right place for explanations of how this IT stuff works...)

Referring to the extracts from Microsoft Learn posted above:
'discrete' (discreta refers to the fact that when a VM requires the resources of a PCIe device (GPU, sound processor, or whatever), it will trigger an assignment protocol which disconnects (dismount/desmontar) that PCIe device from its current host (user) and transfers access to the VM. This process necessarily transfers the entire resource to the VM, and the original host loses all access; hence the term 'discrete' to refer to the assignment process - it assigns on an 'all or nothing' basis - i.e. it is not possible to assign only a part of the resource (and less still is it possible to share the resource between the old and new hosts).

https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows-server/virtualizat...
acceleration-in-windows-server#discrete-device-assignment-dda
Discrete Device Assignment (DDA), also known as GPU pass-through, allows you to dedicate one or more physical GPUs to a virtual machine. In a DDA deployment, virtualized workloads run on the native driver and typically have full access to the GPU's functionality.
A DDA deployment can accelerate only a limited number of virtual machines, since each physical GPU can provide acceleration to at most one VM.

ES
La asignación de dispositivos discreta (DDA), también conocida como paso a través de GPU, permite dedicar una o varias GPU físicas a una máquina virtual. En las implementaciones de DDA, las cargas de trabajo virtualizadas se ejecutan en el controlador nativo y normalmente tienen acceso total a la funcionalidad de la GPU.
Una implementación de DDA solo puede acelerar un número limitado de máquinas virtuales, ya que cada GPU física no puede proporcionar aceleración a más de una máquina virtual.


We can note in passing the following, on the same page under the heading 'RemoteFX vs vGPU':
RemoteFX vGPU is a graphics virtualization technology that allows a single physical GPU to be shared among multiple virtual machines.
IOW, PCIe resource sharing is possible with Remote FX (deprecated - see the purple warning note), but not with DDA.
Note from asker:
Thanks Jennifer, Not sure at all (I am not as reassured as you by the excerpts you mention). Desmontar o asignar el dispositivo no implica que sea discreta la asignación en lugar del dispositivo. Otras fuentes más o menos fiables (DELL y CNI) apuestan por "dispositivos integrados": https://www.dell.com/support/kbdoc/es-es/000106925/how-to-configure-a-gpu-using-undiscreto-device-assignment-dda-on-ubuntu-hu%c3%a9sped-operating-system?lang=es https://www.ccn-cert.cni.es/pdf/guias/series-ccn-stic/guias-de-acceso-publico-ccn-stic/3516-ccn-stic-578-implatacion-de-seguridad-en-ms-hyper-v-sobre-windows-server-2016/file.html La que más me convence es intel (https://www.intel.es/content/www/es/es/support/articles/000057824/graphics.html), en el sentido de que los gráficos (tarjetas) son periféricos. Aquí se ve discreto/periférico vs integrado. Tiene sentido?
That's exactly what I needed, a good clear IT explanation. Me despejaste las dudas Jennifer, muchísimas gracias!!!
Peer comment(s):

agree Juan Gil : Totalmente de acuerdo; lo discreto es la asignación, no el dispositivo.
9 mins
Gracias Juan.
agree slothm : De acuerdo con el comentario de Juan.
28 mins
agree Andrew Bramhall
1 hr
Something went wrong...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer. Comment: "Muchísimas gracias por la ayuda!"
-1
1 hr

asignación de dispositivo discreto

I'm with you.....cheers.
Note from asker:
Hola Antonio, ¿tienes alguna fuente o explicación que lo justifique?
Peer comment(s):

disagree Jennifer Levey : Your webref is inconsistent. In different parts of the text it says: asignación discreta de dispositivos and Asignación de dispositivos discreta (DDA) BUT, nowhere does it say asignación de dispositivo discreto.
53 mins
Thanks, Jennifer...I appreciate very much your pointing out my mistake ─as usual─ and providing the right answer so we can all learn from you
Something went wrong...
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search